Attaché au mât du navire de Neurath

Carrie Jenkins (du groupe de musique rationaliste The Monads), épistémologue et métaphysicienne à Nottingham, nous met en garde contre le chant des Sirènes holistes de Quine sur la signification.



Paroles :

He’ll play upon
Your naturalistic intuitions
He’ll lure you in
With the promise of positions that you love
Like realism about numbers and sets
And the view that philosophy’s continuous with science.

And then you’re caught in the web
No support from the a priori
All aboard Neurath’s ship
It will all be fine
But you’re tied to the mast
It’s all a posteriori
Here on in; have a blast
With Willard Van Orman Quine.

He looks so good
Next to Carnap, Ayer and Chisholm
And there’s nothing wrong
With confirmational holism;
It’s quite nice as an account of how theories face the tribunal of
experience.
Mmm yeah.

But step away when he starts
Talking about the analytic.
Meaning’s not that strange in being tricky to define.
And it comes in small bits;
Not all holism’s terrific.
Keep your head; keep your wits

Round Willard Van Orman Quine.

Rateau de la Méduse par Phiip